Buffalo Criminal Defense Lawyers
The Buffalo criminal defense lawyers at Trbovich Law Firm defend people charged with misdemeanors, felonies, drug offenses, assault, domestic violence, theft, and federal crimes across Erie County, Niagara County, and Western New York. A New York criminal charge can bring jail, probation, fines, an order of protection, and a criminal record, so the first decisions after an arrest matter.
Need legal assistance?
If you find yourself on the wrong side of the law, let us put our knowledge and experience to work for you.
☎ Call NowTrbovich Law Firm is led by Thomas Trbovich, a cum laude graduate of SUNY Buffalo School of Law who has been admitted to practice in New York since 1997. Partner Suzanne Garvey served as a prosecutor with the Erie County District Attorney's Office from 1990 until her retirement in March 2023. That background gives our Buffalo criminal defense attorneys a working view of how prosecutors build and evaluate cases. From offices in Buffalo, Grand Island, and Lockport, the firm handles criminal matters throughout the seven counties of Western New York, alongside the DWI and traffic practice described on the Trbovich Law Firm home page.
What Should You Do Right After an Arrest in Buffalo?
After an arrest in Buffalo, stay calm, say clearly that you want a lawyer, and do not answer questions about the incident. Keep every paper the police or court gives you, write down what happened while it is fresh, and do not discuss the case by phone, text, or social media, because those statements can become evidence.
Jail phone calls are typically recorded, and a casual explanation to a friend can end up in a prosecutor's file. The steps below protect the defenses our Erie County criminal defense lawyers can raise later in the case:
- Ask for a lawyer, then stop talking. Once you ask for counsel, police questioning about the offense should stop. Statements made after that request can be challenged.
- Do not consent to searches. Politely decline consent to search your phone, car, or home. Declining is not a crime, and it preserves a later challenge to any search.
- Keep the paperwork. The appearance ticket, felony complaint, securing order, and any order of protection list the charge, the statute, the court, and your next date.
- Write down the timeline. Note where you were stopped, what officers said, who was present, and whether body cameras appeared to be recording.
- Follow any order of protection exactly. Contact with a protected person, even if that person reaches out first, can lead to a separate charge of criminal contempt under Penal Law 215.50 or 215.51.
- Show up to every court date. Missing a date can lead to a bench warrant and, in some cases, a bail jumping charge under Penal Law 215.55 through 215.57.
What Happens at an Arraignment in Buffalo City Court or a Town Court?
An arraignment is the first court appearance on a criminal charge. The judge informs you of the charge, confirms you have a lawyer, takes a plea (usually not guilty at this stage), decides release conditions, and sets the next date. Inside the City of Buffalo, criminal cases generally begin in Buffalo City Court, and elsewhere in the town or village court where the offense allegedly happened.
Misdemeanor cases usually stay in the local criminal court from arraignment through trial. Felony cases begin in the local court on a felony complaint, then move to Erie County Court (or Niagara County Court for Niagara County cases) after a grand jury votes an indictment. Under Criminal Procedure Law 180.80, a person held in custody on a felony complaint generally must be released if the prosecution has not obtained grand jury action or held a preliminary hearing within 120 hours, or 144 hours when a weekend or holiday falls in that period.
Not every case starts with an overnight arrest. Many misdemeanors begin with a desk appearance ticket under CPL Article 150, which sets a future arraignment date. The guide on desk appearance tickets in Buffalo explains that process, and the post on DWI arraignments in Erie County covers what is different when the charge is impaired driving. At arraignment, a judge can decide:
- Release on recognizance, release with non-monetary conditions, or bail, under CPL 510.10
- A temporary order of protection under CPL 530.12 or 530.13
- Suspension of a driver's license pending prosecution in DWI cases
- Assignment of counsel and the next court date
What Is the Difference Between a Violation, a Misdemeanor, and a Felony in New York?
New York ranks offenses by their maximum sentence. A violation, such as harassment in the second degree, carries up to 15 days in jail and is not a crime. A class B misdemeanor carries up to 3 months, a class A misdemeanor up to 364 days, and a felony can carry more than one year in state prison.
The classification controls more than the sentence. It decides which court hears the case, how long the prosecution has to be ready for trial, and what shows up on a background check. The definitions come from Penal Law 10.00 and the sentencing ranges from Penal Law 70.00 and 70.15:
- Violation: up to 15 days (Penal Law 70.15(4)). Examples include disorderly conduct (Penal Law 240.20) and harassment in the second degree (Penal Law 240.26).
- Class B misdemeanor: up to 3 months (Penal Law 70.15(2)).
- Class A misdemeanor: up to 364 days (Penal Law 70.15(1)). Examples include petit larceny (Penal Law 155.25) and assault in the third degree (Penal Law 120.00).
- Felony, class E through class A: state prison terms under Penal Law 70.00 and 70.02. Examples include grand larceny in the fourth degree (class E, Penal Law 155.30) and burglary in the third degree (class D, Penal Law 140.20).
The Buffalo misdemeanor defense lawyer and Buffalo felony defense attorney pages explain each level in more detail.
Will You Go to Jail for a Criminal Charge in New York?
Jail is possible on any misdemeanor or felony, but it is not automatic. New York judges can impose a conditional discharge, probation, a fine, community service, or jail, depending on the charge. A prior record, mandatory sentencing rules, and the strength of the evidence determine which of those options the law allows.
The sentencing options New York law provides include:
- Conditional discharge under Penal Law 65.05: no jail or probation, but conditions apply for a set period
- Probation under Penal Law 65.00: supervision in the community with conditions
- Fines under Penal Law 80.05: up to $1,000 for a class A misdemeanor and up to $500 for a class B misdemeanor
- Jail or prison under Penal Law 70.15 and 70.00
- Adjournment in contemplation of dismissal (ACD) under CPL 170.55: not a conviction or a sentence. The case is dismissed and sealed after six months (one year in some family offense cases) if no new issues arise.
Some charges limit those options. Violent felony offenses and cases involving a prior felony conviction can carry mandatory prison terms under Penal Law 70.02 and 70.06. Knowing early which rules apply shapes every decision that follows.
Can Criminal Charges Be Dismissed or Reduced in New York?
New York law provides several routes to dismissal or reduction, though none is automatic. A charge can be dismissed for a defective accusatory instrument, a speedy trial violation, suppressed evidence, or in the interest of justice, and prosecutors can agree to reduce a charge through plea negotiation.
- Defective accusatory instrument: a complaint or information that does not allege every element of the offense can be dismissed under CPL 100.40, 170.30, and 170.35.
- Speedy trial: under CPL 30.30, the prosecution must be ready for trial within six months for a felony, 90 days for a class A misdemeanor, 60 days for a class B misdemeanor, and 30 days when only a violation is charged, not counting excludable time.
- Suppression: evidence from an unlawful stop or search, involuntary statements, and suggestive identifications can be challenged under CPL Article 710.
- Interest of justice: courts can dismiss charges under CPL 170.40 (local court cases) and CPL 210.40 (indictments) after weighing factors set out in those statutes.
- Plea negotiation: prosecutors may agree to a reduced charge or an ACD, depending on the facts and the record.
The posts on what happens after an indictment and whether charges can be dropped after an indictment cover the felony side of these options.
What Criminal Charges Do Our Buffalo Criminal Defense Lawyers Handle?
Our Buffalo criminal defense lawyers handle state and federal charges ranging from violations and misdemeanors to serious felonies. The main practice areas are listed below, each with its own page explaining the statutes, penalties, and defenses that apply to that charge in Erie County and Western New York courts.
- Felonies: grand jury practice, indictments, and Erie County Court cases. See the felony defense attorney page, including burglary defense, drug trafficking, and felony theft.
- Misdemeanors: petit larceny, disorderly conduct, criminal mischief, and drug possession.
- Assault: the assault charge lawyer page covers every degree, with separate pages for misdemeanor assault, simple assault, and felony assault under Penal Law 120.05 and 120.10.
- Domestic violence: family offense charges and orders of protection. See the domestic violence defense lawyer page.
- Drug crimes: possession and sale charges under Penal Law Article 220. See the drug defense lawyer page.
- Theft and larceny: the grand larceny defense lawyer page explains the dollar thresholds for each degree.
- Criminal trespass: charges under Penal Law 140.05 through 140.17. See the criminal trespass lawyer page.
- White-collar and computer crimes: fraud, embezzlement, and cyber crime. See the white-collar crime lawyer page.
- Federal crimes: charges prosecuted in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of New York. See the federal crime defense page.
- Homicide: murder and manslaughter charges. See the murder defense lawyer page.
- Sex offenses and young people: sex offense allegations, and cases involving teenagers and young adults, including youthful offender treatment under CPL Article 720.
- DWI and traffic crimes: see the Buffalo DWI defense lawyer, DWAI lawyer, felony DWI lawyer, and traffic ticket defense lawyer pages for reckless driving and moving violations.
To find the nearest office, see criminal defense attorney offices near you.
How Does Discovery Work in a New York Criminal Case?
Discovery is the prosecution's duty to turn over its evidence. Under CPL Article 245, prosecutors must share police reports, body camera and 911 recordings, witness information, lab results, and other material within 20 days of arraignment if you are in custody, or 35 days if you are released, with limited extensions.
After turning over discovery, the prosecution files a certificate of compliance, which it must do before it can announce that it is ready for trial under CPL 30.30. Amendments to Article 245 that took effect on August 7, 2025, require the defense to raise challenges to a certificate of compliance within 35 days of service and to confer with the prosecution first. That makes an early, careful review of the file more important than ever. Discovery under CPL 245.20 includes:
- Written, recorded, and oral statements attributed to you
- Names and contact information of people with relevant information
- Police reports, officers' notes, and body-worn and dashboard camera footage
- 911 calls and radio transmissions
- Lab, forensic, and medical reports
- Search warrant applications and inventories
- Information that tends to undercut the prosecution's case or the credibility of its witnesses
Our Western New York criminal defense attorneys review this material with private investigators, digital forensic examiners, and toxicologists when the case calls for it.
How Does Bail Work in New York After the Bail Reform Laws?
For most misdemeanors and nonviolent felonies, New York judges must release a person at arraignment, either on recognizance or with non-monetary conditions such as supervised release. Cash bail is available only for qualifying offenses listed in CPL 510.10, which include most violent felonies, many domestic violence charges, and certain charges brought while another case is pending.
Amendments in 2020, 2022, and 2023 changed the list of qualifying offenses and the factors a judge may weigh when setting conditions. Release conditions are written on a securing order. Following those conditions and appearing at every date protects your release status, while a missed date can result in a bench warrant. Release arguments at the first appearance are one of the earliest places our Buffalo criminal defense attorneys can affect the course of a case.
How Long Does a Criminal Case Take in Erie County?
A misdemeanor case in Buffalo City Court or a town court often takes several weeks to several months. A felony that goes to a grand jury and then Erie County Court commonly takes longer. Discovery deadlines, motion schedules, hearing dates, and the CPL 30.30 speedy trial clock all shape the timeline.
Most cases move through the same stages: arraignment, discovery, motions, hearings, negotiation, and then trial or a plea. Adjournments are common while discovery is completed and motions are decided. Delay is not always bad for the defense, but it should be deliberate. Tracking which adjournments count against the prosecution under CPL 30.30 is part of how our Buffalo criminal defense lawyers manage a case from the first date.
How Much Does a Criminal Defense Lawyer Cost in Buffalo?
The cost of a criminal defense lawyer in Buffalo depends on the charge level, the court, how much evidence must be reviewed, whether hearings or a trial are needed, and whether investigators or other retained professionals are involved. Fees are discussed during the first meeting, and Trbovich Law Firm accepts credit and debit cards.
A violation-level charge in a town court and a felony indictment in Erie County Court involve very different amounts of work. The post on how much a criminal lawyer costs explains the main factors that drive fees in Western New York.
Can a Criminal Record Be Sealed in New York?
Yes, in many cases. Dismissals and acquittals are sealed under CPL 160.50, and most violation convictions are sealed under CPL 160.55. The Clean Slate Act (CPL 160.57) automatically seals eligible misdemeanor convictions after three years and eligible felony convictions after eight years, with exceptions such as sex offenses and most class A felonies.
- Clean Slate Act timing: the law took effect on November 16, 2024, and the court system has until November 16, 2027, to seal older eligible convictions. The waiting period runs from sentencing or release from incarceration, and a new conviction restarts it.
- Clean Slate Act conditions: no pending charge and no current probation or parole supervision.
- Discretionary sealing: under CPL 160.59, a person can apply to seal up to two convictions, no more than one of them a felony, after ten years.
Sealing is the last stage of a case, but the earlier stages decide what there is to seal. A dismissal, an ACD, or a plea to a violation leaves a very different record than a misdemeanor or felony conviction.
How Do Our Buffalo Criminal Defense Lawyers Handle These Cases?
A criminal defense lawyer tests the prosecution's case at every stage, from arrest through sentencing. Our Buffalo criminal defense lawyers prepare each case as if it is going to trial, starting with the stop, the search, and the statements. That preparation supports a stronger position at a suppression hearing, at the negotiating table, and in front of a jury.
- Arrest and arraignment: release arguments under CPL 510.10, review of any order of protection, and, in DWI cases, the suspension pending prosecution.
- Discovery and investigation: review of CPL Article 245 material, including body camera footage, 911 recordings, and lab reports, with private investigators and digital forensic examiners where needed.
- Motions and hearings: omnibus motions, suppression hearings under CPL Article 710 that challenge searches, statements, probable cause, and identifications, speedy trial motions under CPL 30.30, and motions to dismiss.
- Plea negotiation: a plea on the right terms is welcome. A plea that gives away a real defense is not.
- Trial: bench or jury trial in the local criminal court or in Erie County Court, with cross-examination of officers and witnesses.
- Sentencing and record relief: alternatives to incarceration, youthful offender treatment where eligible, and sealing under CPL 160.57 and 160.59.
Why Choose Thomas Trbovich for Your Criminal Defense Case?
Thomas Trbovich has been admitted to practice in New York since 1997 and graduated cum laude from SUNY Buffalo School of Law. His practice covers DUI and DWI, criminal, felony, misdemeanor, and traffic cases in Western New York, and he works with partner Suzanne Garvey, who spent more than three decades as an Erie County prosecutor.
- Thomas Trbovich: J.D., cum laude, SUNY Buffalo School of Law, 1997; admitted in New York, 1997
- Thomas Trbovich: M.S. in Economics, SUNY Buffalo, 1990; B.S., Skidmore College, 1988
- Suzanne Garvey: J.D., magna cum laude, SUNY Buffalo School of Law, 1989; B.S.S., summa cum laude, SUNY Buffalo, 1986
- Suzanne Garvey: prosecutor with the Erie County District Attorney's Office from 1990 until March 2023, with most of her final seven years in the Vehicular Crimes Bureau
Contact Our Buffalo Criminal Defense Lawyers
If you have been arrested, received an appearance ticket, or learned that a warrant may be out for you, talk with our Buffalo criminal defense lawyers before your next court date. Bring the appearance ticket or complaint, the securing order, any order of protection, and your notes about the arrest to the first meeting.
Need legal assistance?
If you find yourself on the wrong side of the law, let us put our knowledge and experience to work for you.
☎ Call Now

