Buffalo Murder Defense Attorney
As a Buffalo murder defense attorney, Thomas Trbovich defends people charged with murder, manslaughter, criminally negligent homicide, and vehicular homicide in Erie County and Western New York. A homicide charge in New York can carry a sentence of up to life in prison, so the defense starts with the evidence, the forensic work, and the mental state the prosecution must prove.
Need legal assistance?
If you find yourself on the wrong side of the law, let us put our knowledge and experience to work for you.
☎ Call NowTrbovich Law Firm handles homicide cases as part of its Buffalo criminal defense practice, from the first appearance through grand jury, trial in Erie County Court or State Supreme Court, and sentencing. Partner Suzanne Garvey served as a prosecutor with the Erie County District Attorney's Office from 1990 until March 2023, spending most of her final seven years in the Vehicular Crimes Bureau, which handled fatal crash cases countywide. That background gives our Buffalo homicide defense attorneys a direct view of how death cases are investigated and charged.
What Is the Difference Between Murder and Manslaughter in New York?
The difference between murder and manslaughter in New York is mental state. Murder in the second degree generally requires intent to cause death. Manslaughter in the first degree involves intent to cause serious physical injury that results in death, and manslaughter in the second degree involves recklessly causing death. Criminally negligent homicide covers a failure to perceive a deadly risk.
New York does not use the terms "first-degree" and "second-degree" murder the way many other states and television shows do. In New York, murder in the second degree under Penal Law 125.25 is the most commonly charged murder count, and murder in the first degree under Penal Law 125.27 is reserved for intentional killings with specific aggravating factors. The same death can be charged at very different levels depending on what the prosecution believes the person intended.
- Intent to kill: murder in the second degree, Penal Law 125.25(1)
- Intent to cause serious physical injury, resulting in death: manslaughter in the first degree, Penal Law 125.20(1)
- Recklessly causing death: manslaughter in the second degree, Penal Law 125.15
- Criminal negligence causing death: criminally negligent homicide, Penal Law 125.10
What Are the Degrees of Homicide in New York?
Penal Law Article 125 sets out New York's homicide offenses, from criminally negligent homicide, a class E felony, to murder in the first degree, a class A-I felony that can carry life without parole. Vehicular manslaughter and aggravated vehicular homicide cover deaths caused by impaired drivers.
- Criminally negligent homicide (Penal Law 125.10): class E felony, up to 4 years
- Vehicular manslaughter in the second degree (Penal Law 125.12): class D felony, causing death while driving impaired
- Vehicular manslaughter in the first degree (Penal Law 125.13): class C felony, with aggravating factors such as a prior DWI or a suspended license
- Aggravated vehicular homicide (Penal Law 125.14): class B felony, the most serious vehicular homicide charge
- Manslaughter in the second degree (Penal Law 125.15): class C felony, up to 15 years
- Manslaughter in the first degree (Penal Law 125.20): class B violent felony, 5 to 25 years for a first-time felony offender
- Murder in the second degree (Penal Law 125.25): class A-I felony, minimum of 15 to 25 years and a maximum of life
- Murder in the first degree (Penal Law 125.27): class A-I felony, minimum of 20 to 25 years and a maximum of life, or life without parole
Manslaughter in the second degree is not classified as a violent felony offense under Penal Law 70.02, which means the sentencing options are broader than for manslaughter in the first degree, including probation in some circumstances.
What Is the Sentence for Murder in the Second Degree in New York?
Murder in the second degree is a class A-I felony. Under Penal Law 70.00, the sentence is an indeterminate term with a minimum of 15 to 25 years and a maximum of life in prison. Certain forms of second-degree murder, such as a killing committed during specified sexual offenses against a child under Penal Law 125.25(5), require life without parole.
An indeterminate sentence such as "25 years to life" means the person is not eligible for parole release until the minimum term is served, and the Board of Parole decides release after that. New York abolished the death penalty in practice after the Court of Appeals' 2004 decision in People v. LaValle, and the most serious sentence now is life without parole, which is allowed for murder in the first degree under Penal Law 70.00(5).
Because the sentencing gap between murder and manslaughter is so large, the evidence of intent is often the most important issue in a homicide case. Whether a death was intended, whether it resulted from a fight that went too far, or whether it was an accident can change a sentence by decades.
What Happens After a Murder or Homicide Arrest in Buffalo?
After a homicide arrest in Buffalo, the person is arraigned on a felony complaint in Buffalo City Court or a local town court. That local court cannot release a person charged with a class A felony such as murder, so any bail application goes to Erie County Court or State Supreme Court. The case then moves toward a grand jury.
- Arraignment: the charge is read, counsel appears, and the court addresses custody. Under CPL 530.20(2)(a), a city, town, or village court may not order release when the charge is a class A felony.
- Felony hearing or grand jury: under CPL 180.80, a person held on a felony complaint must generally be released if there is no preliminary hearing or grand jury action within 120 hours, or 144 hours over a weekend or holiday.
- Grand jury testimony: under CPL 190.50, the accused has a right to testify before the grand jury after written notice. That decision should be made only with counsel.
- Indictment: if the grand jury votes an indictment, the case moves to Erie County Court or State Supreme Court for arraignment on the indictment. The post on what happens after an indictment explains this stage.
- No statute of limitations: under CPL 30.10(2)(a), there is no time limit for prosecuting a class A felony, including murder.
Families should know that the person arrested should not discuss the case on jail phones or video visits, which are typically recorded, and should not talk with detectives without counsel present.
Is There Bail for a Murder Charge in New York?
Bail can be set on a murder charge in New York, but only by a superior court, and murder is a qualifying offense under CPL 510.10, so a judge may set bail or order remand. The judge considers factors such as ties to the community, criminal history, the strength of the evidence, and the likelihood of returning to court.
A bail application in a homicide case is usually made to an Erie County Court or State Supreme Court judge after arraignment. Preparing it well means gathering documentation about employment, family, residence, health, and community support, and presenting the weaknesses in the prosecution's case. Release conditions, when granted, can include electronic monitoring and supervision. The outcome of a bail application is never guaranteed, but a thorough application gives the court the information it needs.
What Defenses Apply to a Murder or Manslaughter Charge?
The defenses to a murder or manslaughter charge in New York include justification (self-defense or defense of others), lack of the required intent, extreme emotional disturbance, misidentification, false or unreliable confessions, alibi, problems with causation, and challenges to forensic and digital evidence. The right defense depends on the charge, the facts, and the evidence.
- Justification (Penal Law 35.15(2)): deadly physical force may be used when a person reasonably believes another is using or about to use deadly physical force. There is a duty to retreat when it can be done with complete safety, except in your own home when you are not the initial aggressor. Deadly force may also be justified to stop certain violent felonies, such as robbery or kidnapping.
- Mental state: evidence that there was no intent to kill can reduce murder to manslaughter, or manslaughter to a lesser charge.
- Extreme emotional disturbance: an affirmative defense to intentional murder under Penal Law 125.25(1)(a), discussed below.
- Identification: eyewitness identifications made under stress, in poor lighting, or across racial lines can be unreliable and can be challenged at a Wade hearing under CPL Article 710.
- Statements: under CPL 60.45(3), custodial interrogations in murder and certain other serious felony cases at a detention facility generally must be electronically recorded. Statements taken in violation of the law or Miranda can be challenged at a Huntley hearing.
- Alibi: evidence that the accused was elsewhere, which requires notice to the prosecution under CPL 250.20.
- Causation: in some cases, an independent intervening cause, such as a separate medical event, can break the chain between the act and the death.
What Is Extreme Emotional Disturbance in a New York Murder Case?
Extreme emotional disturbance is an affirmative defense to intentional murder under Penal Law 125.25(1)(a). If the defense proves by a preponderance of the evidence that the person acted under an extreme emotional disturbance with a reasonable explanation or excuse, the charge is reduced from murder to manslaughter in the first degree under Penal Law 125.20(2).
Extreme emotional disturbance does not excuse the act entirely. It recognizes that a killing committed under an overwhelming emotional state is less culpable than a cold, deliberate one. The reasonableness of the explanation is judged from the viewpoint of a person in the defendant's situation as the defendant believed it to be. Raising this defense often involves forensic psychiatrists or psychologists and careful decisions about what evidence to present, since it concedes the act while contesting the degree.
What Are Felony Murder and Depraved Indifference Murder?
Felony murder under Penal Law 125.25(3) applies when a death occurs during certain felonies, such as robbery, burglary, kidnapping, arson, or rape, even if no one intended to kill. Depraved indifference murder under Penal Law 125.25(2) applies to reckless conduct creating a grave risk of death under circumstances showing utter disregard for human life.
Felony murder has a statutory affirmative defense for a non-shooting participant. Under Penal Law 125.25(3), the defense applies when the accused did not commit or aid the homicidal act, was not armed with a deadly weapon, had no reasonable ground to believe any other participant was armed, and had no reasonable ground to believe any participant intended to engage in conduct likely to cause death or serious injury.
Depraved indifference murder has been narrowed by New York's Court of Appeals. In People v. Feingold (2006), the court held that depraved indifference is a culpable mental state, and later decisions have limited it to rare cases of extreme wickedness or indifference. Many cases charged as depraved indifference are better analyzed as manslaughter, and challenging the charge is a central part of the defense.
How Is Forensic and Digital Evidence Challenged in a Homicide Case?
Homicide cases often rest on forensic and digital evidence: autopsy findings, DNA, firearms and ballistics analysis, cell phone location data, social media, and video. Each type of evidence can be tested through discovery, defense analysts, pretrial hearings, and cross-examination. New York courts apply the Frye standard to decide whether scientific evidence is generally accepted.
- Autopsy and cause of death: the medical examiner's findings on cause, manner, and time of death can be reviewed by an independent forensic pathologist.
- DNA: mixtures, low-level samples, and probabilistic genotyping software can be challenged by an independent DNA analyst.
- Firearms and ballistics: toolmark comparisons and shooting reconstructions can be reviewed by a firearms examiner.
- Cell phone location data: under Carpenter v. United States (2018), police generally need a warrant to obtain historical cell site location records, and the accuracy of location estimates can be challenged by a digital forensic examiner.
- Video: surveillance and phone video can be enhanced, timed, and compared, and it may show events differently than witnesses describe them.
Discovery under CPL Article 245 requires the prosecution to turn over lab reports, underlying data, and expert information, which is the starting point for every forensic review.
What If the Death Happened in a Car Crash?
When a death results from a car crash, the charge may be criminally negligent homicide, manslaughter in the second degree, vehicular manslaughter in the second or first degree, or aggravated vehicular homicide. Vehicular homicide charges usually require proof that the driver was impaired by alcohol or drugs under Vehicle and Traffic Law 1192 and that the impairment caused the death.
Fatal crash cases turn on accident reconstruction, toxicology, event data recorder information, and medical causation. Suzanne Garvey's years in the Erie County District Attorney's Office Vehicular Crimes Bureau, which handled serious injury and fatal crash cases countywide, give our Buffalo homicide defense attorneys detailed knowledge of how these cases are investigated, from blood draws and toxicology reports to crash reconstruction. Related information appears on the Buffalo felony DWI lawyer page and in the posts on what vehicular manslaughter is and vehicular manslaughter sentences.
How Long Does a Murder Case Take in Erie County?
A murder case in Erie County commonly takes a year or more from arrest to trial, and complex cases with extensive forensic evidence can take longer. New York's statutory speedy trial rule, CPL 30.30, does not apply to homicide charges under Penal Law 125.10 through 125.27, though the constitutional right to a speedy trial under CPL 30.20 still applies.
The timeline is shaped by grand jury proceedings, discovery, forensic testing, pretrial hearings, and trial scheduling in Erie County Court or State Supreme Court. A murder trial itself often lasts one to several weeks. After a conviction, an appeal goes to the Appellate Division, Fourth Department, which hears appeals from Erie County and the rest of Western New York.
How Do Our Buffalo Murder Defense Attorneys Handle These Cases?
Our Buffalo murder defense attorneys prepare every homicide case for trial from the first day, starting with the scene, the forensic evidence, and every statement. That preparation is what supports a strong bail application, a grand jury strategy, pretrial motions, informed plea decisions, and a defense in front of a jury.
- Arrest and arraignment: appearing at the first court date, protecting the right to remain silent, and preparing a superior court bail application.
- Grand jury: advising on testimony under CPL 190.50 and presenting information that may support a lower charge.
- Investigation: independent investigation with private investigators, and review of autopsy, DNA, ballistics, cell phone, and video evidence with forensic pathologists, DNA analysts, firearms examiners, accident reconstructionists, and digital forensic examiners.
- Motions and hearings: motions to dismiss or reduce counts under CPL 210.20 and 210.30, Huntley, Mapp, Dunaway, and Wade hearings under CPL Article 710, and Frye challenges to scientific evidence.
- Plea negotiation: a plea on the right terms is welcome. A plea that gives away a real justification or mental-state defense is not.
- Trial, sentencing, and appeal: jury trial in Erie County Court or State Supreme Court, sentencing advocacy, and appeals to the Appellate Division, Fourth Department.
For other serious felony charges, see the Buffalo felony defense attorney and Buffalo aggravated assault lawyer pages.
Why Choose Thomas Trbovich for Your Murder Defense Case?
Thomas Trbovich has been admitted to practice in New York since 1997 and graduated cum laude from SUNY Buffalo School of Law. His practice covers felony, criminal, misdemeanor, and DWI cases in Western New York. He works with partner Suzanne Garvey, whose prosecution career in Erie County included fatal crash and serious injury cases in the Vehicular Crimes Bureau.
- Thomas Trbovich: J.D., cum laude, SUNY Buffalo School of Law, 1997; admitted in New York, 1997
- Thomas Trbovich: M.S. in Economics, SUNY Buffalo, 1990; B.S., Skidmore College, 1988
- Suzanne Garvey: J.D., magna cum laude, SUNY Buffalo School of Law, 1989; B.S.S., summa cum laude, SUNY Buffalo, 1986
- Suzanne Garvey: prosecutor with the Erie County District Attorney's Office from 1990 until March 2023, with most of her final seven years in the Vehicular Crimes Bureau handling felony DWI, serious injury, and fatal crash cases countywide
Contact Our Buffalo Murder Defense Attorneys
If you or a family member has been arrested for murder, manslaughter, or another homicide charge in Buffalo, Erie County, Niagara County, or anywhere in Western New York, or if detectives want to ask questions, talk with our Buffalo murder defense attorneys right away. Bring the felony complaint, the court date, any paperwork from the arrest or a search, and the names of people who may have information to the first meeting with Trbovich Law Firm.
Need legal assistance?
If you find yourself on the wrong side of the law, let us put our knowledge and experience to work for you.
☎ Call Now

