Can a Breathalyzer Test Be Wrong?
Can a Breathalyzer Test Be Wrong?
Can a breathalyzer be wrong? Yes. A breath test estimates the alcohol in your blood from a sample of your breath. Mouth alcohol, acid reflux, a poorly kept machine, a rushed officer, or bad timing can all push the number off. In a New York driving while intoxicated case, that number can shape the charge, your license, and your future.
At Trbovich Law Firm, our Buffalo DWI defense attorneys look closely at every breath test result behind a charge. Our team represents drivers across Erie County, Niagara County, and Western New York. Arrested after a breath test? Our Buffalo DWI defense attorneys can review how the test was given and whether the result holds up.
How Accurate Are Breathalyzers Used in New York DWI Arrests?
Breathalyzers used at the police station are built to be accurate, but they are not perfect. The machine does not measure your blood. It measures alcohol in your breath and converts it into a blood alcohol number using a fixed formula. When your body, the machine, or the process does not fit that formula, the result can be off.
The formula assumes every person's breath and blood hold alcohol in the same ratio. Real people vary. Body temperature, breathing pattern, and blood makeup can all change how much alcohol shows up in a breath sample.
So are breathalyzers accurate? They can be close when everything goes right. The question in a DWI case is whether everything went right for you, on that night, with that machine and that officer.
What Can Cause a False Positive on a Breath Test After a DWI Stop in Western New York?
A false positive breathalyzer result means the machine reads higher than your true blood alcohol level. Common causes include mouth alcohol, acid reflux, and dental work that traps alcohol. Some mouthwashes, breath sprays, and medical or diet conditions can also play a role. Any of these may raise the number without more alcohol in your blood.
Breath machines are designed to read air from deep in the lungs. Alcohol in the mouth or throat can reach the machine first. That can make the reading jump well above the true level.
Factors our Buffalo DWI defense attorneys look for include:
- Mouth alcohol. A recent drink, a burp, or vomiting shortly before the test can leave alcohol in the mouth.
- Acid reflux or heartburn. Reflux can bring alcohol from the stomach up into the throat and mouth.
- Dentures, braces, or dental work. These can trap small amounts of alcohol or food that hold alcohol.
- Mouthwash and breath sprays. Many contain alcohol. Used just before a test, they may raise the reading.
- Diabetes, fasting, or very low carb diets. These may create chemicals in the breath that some machines can confuse with alcohol.
- Work exposure. Paint, fuel, and cleaning fumes breathed in over a long shift may affect some readings.
Police are supposed to watch a driver for a set period before the breath test. The goal is to make sure nothing enters the mouth and no burping or vomiting happens. If that watch period was cut short or not done, it may become an issue in your case.
Is the Roadside Portable Breath Test the Same as the Breath Test at the Police Station in New York?
No. The portable breath test at the roadside is a small handheld screening device. It helps an officer decide whether to make an arrest. The chemical test of breath at the station uses a larger instrument. In New York, the station test is usually the number the prosecutor relies on to prove the level of alcohol.
The roadside device is less exact than the station machine. It is often used within minutes of your last drink, when mouth alcohol is more likely. Still, it can play a role in whether the officer had enough reason to arrest you.
That matters at the probable cause hearing on the stop and the arrest. If the arrest itself was not lawful, the station breath test that followed may be challenged too. Our Buffalo DWI lawyers review both tests and how each one was used.
How Do Breath Testing Instrument Maintenance and Calibration Records Affect a New York DWI Case?
Every breath testing machine used for evidence in New York must be checked and kept in working order. Breathalyzer calibration records show whether the machine was tested against a known alcohol sample and passed. Missing, late, or failed records may raise real questions about whether the result from your test can be trusted.
Police agencies across New York use approved breath testing instruments at the station. Those machines need regular checks, repairs, and updates. The records behind each machine tell a story about how well it has been kept.
Records our Buffalo DWI defense team may request include:
- Calibration and maintenance logs for the specific machine used in your test.
- Records of the known alcohol solution used to check the machine, including when it was made and replaced.
- Repair history and any error messages the machine showed before or after your test.
- The test printout, known as the ticket, and whether it shows a clean result.
- Records of other tests run on the same machine around the same date.
These records are part of the discovery process. Discovery is the exchange of evidence between the prosecutor and the defense. Our attorneys compare what the records show with what the police report claims.
Does the Officer Who Gave the Breath Test in Erie County Need a Permit and Training?
Yes. In New York, the person who runs an evidence breath test must hold a permit from the New York State Department of Health. Officers must be trained on the specific machine and follow a set step by step process. An expired permit or skipped step may affect how much weight the result carries.
Breath testing is not just pushing a button. The officer must confirm the watch period, enter your details, and follow each step the machine calls for. Each step is there to protect the accuracy of the number.
Our Buffalo DWI attorneys look at whether the officer's permit was current on the date of your test. The team also looks at whether the steps were followed in the right order. The dashcam and body camera footage can show what happened in the testing room in real time.
Can the Timing of a Breath Test Change the Result in a Buffalo DWI Arrest?
Yes. Alcohol keeps moving into your blood for a while after your last drink. Your level may be rising when you are pulled over and still rising at the station. A breath test taken later may show a higher number than you had while driving. Timing also matters under New York's rules for when a chemical test is given.
This is often called rising blood alcohol. A person who had a drink shortly before driving may have been under the legal limit at the wheel. By the time the station test is given, the level may have climbed.
New York also sets time limits on when a chemical test should be given after an arrest. Our Buffalo DWI defense lawyers check the time of the stop, the arrest, and the test. Gaps in that timeline can matter to how a result is used.
What Blood Alcohol Levels Matter in a New York Driving While Intoxicated Charge?
In New York, a breath test of 0.08 or higher can support a per se driving while intoxicated charge. Per se means the charge is based on the number alone. A reading of 0.18 or higher can support aggravated driving while intoxicated. A lower reading may still support driving while ability impaired, a lesser charge.
Because the charge often follows the number, a small error can have a big effect. A reading that is a few points too high may move a case from one charge level to another. That is why the accuracy of the breathalyzer test matters so much.
Prosecutors may also charge common law driving while intoxicated. That theory is based on how you looked, spoke, and drove, not only the number. Our Buffalo DWI defense attorneys review both the breath result and the officer's observations.
What Happens If I Refused the Breathalyzer Test in New York?
If you refused the chemical test at the station, you face a separate refusal hearing at the New York State Department of Motor Vehicles. A refusal can lead to license revocation and a civil penalty, even if the criminal case goes well. The hearing looks at whether the stop, arrest, and refusal warnings were handled properly.
The refusal hearing is separate from your criminal case in Erie County court. It moves on its own schedule and has its own deadlines. Missing the hearing may lead to an automatic loss of your license.
Refusing the roadside portable breath test is treated differently from refusing the chemical test at the station. Our Buffalo DWI lawyers review which test was refused and what warnings you were given. The team can represent you at the refusal hearing and in court.
How Can a Buffalo DWI Defense Attorney Challenge a Breath Test Result in Court?
Our Buffalo DWI defense attorneys can challenge a breath test through pretrial motions, a suppression hearing, and cross examination at trial. A suppression hearing asks the judge to keep evidence out of the case. Arguments may focus on the stop, the arrest, the machine records, the officer's permit, and the test process.
Not every challenge leads to a result being thrown out. What the law allows depends on the facts, the records, and the judge. Our role is to find the weak points and raise every argument the evidence supports.
Areas our Buffalo DWI attorneys may raise include:
- Whether the officer had a lawful reason to stop your vehicle.
- Whether there was enough reason to arrest you before the station test.
- Whether the required watch period was done and recorded.
- Whether the machine was checked, kept up, and working on the test date.
- Whether the officer held a current permit and followed each step.
- Whether a medical condition, diet, or mouth alcohol may explain the reading.
- Whether the video matches what the police report and supporting deposition claim.
Independent scientific review may also help. A toxicologist can look at the machine data, your drinking timeline, and your health history. That review may support or weaken the prosecution's version of events.
Can a Wrong Breathalyzer Result Affect My License, Job, or Immigration Status in New York?
Yes. A breath test of 0.08 or higher can lead to a license suspension at arraignment while the case is pending. A conviction can bring license revocation, the ignition interlock device requirement, fines, and a criminal record. Commercial drivers, professional licensees, and non citizens may face added consequences from the same result.
The ignition interlock device is a small breath tester wired into your vehicle. It must be blown into before the car will start. It is often required after a DWI conviction in New York.
Commercial driver license holders face stricter rules and a lower alcohol limit while driving a commercial vehicle. Nurses, teachers, pilots, and other licensed professionals may have reporting duties. Non citizens may face immigration exposure. Our Buffalo DWI defense team weighs these issues from the start.
How Do Our Buffalo DWI Defense Attorneys Handle Breathalyzer Test Cases?
Our Buffalo DWI defense attorneys follow a staged approach in breath test cases. It starts with early action to protect your license and a close review of the evidence. It continues through motions, negotiation, and trial if needed. Each stage focuses on the facts behind the breath test number.
- Early action. Our team reviews your arraignment, any license suspension, and any refusal hearing date. Deadlines at the Department of Motor Vehicles are tracked from day one.
- Evidence review. Our attorneys request the machine records, the officer's permit, the test ticket, and all video. The team compares each record with the police report.
- Motions and hearings. Our Buffalo DWI lawyers file pretrial motions and may seek a suppression hearing. The goal is to test whether the stop, arrest, and breath result were lawful and reliable.
- Negotiation. Weak points in the breath test can matter in plea negotiation with the Erie County District Attorney's Office or a local prosecutor. Our team explains your options at each step.
- Trial. Your case may go to trial, whether by judge or jury. If it does, our attorneys can cross examine the officer and challenge the breath test.
Why Choose Trbovich Law Firm for a Breathalyzer Challenge in Buffalo?
Trbovich Law Firm focuses on impaired driving defense in Buffalo and across Western New York. Our Buffalo DWI defense attorneys handle cases in house, from the roadside stop through the Department of Motor Vehicles process and trial. The firm studies the science, records, and procedures that shape breath test evidence.
Our team handles driving while intoxicated and driving while ability impaired cases. The firm handles both the criminal case and the separate license process. That lets our attorneys see how a breath test result affects every part of your case.
Contact a Buffalo DWI Defense Attorney About Your Breathalyzer Test
A breath test number is not the end of the story. Think your breathalyzer test was wrong? Our Buffalo DWI defense attorneys can review the records and explain what may be possible in your case. Reach out to Trbovich Law Firm to talk about your breath test and your next steps.
Sources
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration: Alcohol Measurement Devices
- New York State Department of Health, Wadsworth Center: Permit to Perform Breath Alcohol Analysis
Attorney Advertising. This page is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every legal matter depends on its own facts and the law in effect at the time.

